{
  "conclusion": "Option 2 is the only one that produced convincing heavy physical film damage. Option 1 produced a valid RunPod render but the model muted much of the baked-in damage. Option 3 was blocked by Runway provider moderation and produced no video.",
  "created_at": "2026-05-18T22:15:53.705455+00:00",
  "experiment": "newsreel_damage_three_way_test",
  "options": [
    {
      "assessment": "Film damage is visible but substantially muted after I2V; prompt and keyframe override were confirmed in DB.",
      "contact_sheet": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/renders/01KRYHVPK4W10K5TKT6FGNBXK0/option1_contact.jpg",
      "local_mp4": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/renders/01KRYHVPK4W10K5TKT6FGNBXK0/final_prompt_only_stitched.mp4",
      "name": "option1_bake_damage_into_keyframe_then_runpod_i2v",
      "runtime_info": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/renders/01KRYHVPK4W10K5TKT6FGNBXK0/runtime_info.json",
      "status": "completed",
      "url_mp4": "https://storyboard.tojo.team/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/renders/01KRYHVPK4W10K5TKT6FGNBXK0/final_prompt_only_stitched.mp4"
    },
    {
      "assessment": "Best match for severe aged 1933 print: sepia, vignette, tramline scratches, dust, edge grime, flicker, and gate weave are clearly visible.",
      "contact_sheet": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option2_contact.jpg",
      "local_mp4": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option2_controlled_postprocess.mp4",
      "metadata": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option2_controlled_postprocess.json",
      "name": "option2_controlled_aged_film_pass",
      "status": "completed",
      "url_mp4": "https://storyboard.tojo.team/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option2_controlled_postprocess.mp4"
    },
    {
      "assessment": "Runway task 18b36135-c98d-497d-8735-7f0541193fa6 failed with SAFETY.INPUT.THIRD_PARTY; no MP4 output.",
      "metadata": "outputs/storyboards/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option3_runway_seedance2_v2v.json",
      "name": "option3_runway_seedance2_video_to_video",
      "status": "failed",
      "url_metadata": "https://storyboard.tojo.team/01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY/experiments/newsreel-damage-20260518T214448Z/option3_runway_seedance2_v2v.json"
    }
  ],
  "runpod_postflight": {
    "current_spend_per_hr": 0,
    "live_pods": [],
    "volume_count": 0
  },
  "storyboard_id": "01KQMED1HA7D2P1QKMPYW6JYWY"
}